Beware of Greek Debt


Greek government debt crisis

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
  (Redirected from Greek financial crisis)
Greece Greek debt crisis

Greece’s debt percentage between 1999 and 2010 compared to the average of the Eurozone.

From late 2009, fears of a sovereign debt crisis developed among investors concerning Greece’s ability to meet its debt obligations due to strong increase in government debt levels.[1][2] This led to a crisis of confidence, indicated by a widening of bond yield spreads and risk insurance on credit default swapscompared to other countries, most importantly Germany.[3][4]

Downgrading of Greek government debt to junk bond status created alarm in financial markets. On 2 May 2010, the Eurozone countries and the International Monetary Fund agreed on a €110 billion loan for Greece, conditional on the implementation of harsh austerity measures.

In October 2011, Eurozone leaders also agreed on a proposal to write off 50% of Greek debt owed to private creditors, increasing the EFSF to about €1 trillion and requiring European banks to achieve 9% capitalization to reduce the risk of contagion to other countries.




Combined charts of Greece’s GDP and Debt since 1970; also of Deficit since 2000. Absolute terms time series are in current euros.

The Greek economy was one of the fastest growing in the eurozone from 2000 to 2007; during that period, it grew at an annual rate of 4.2% as foreign capital flooded the country.[5] A strong economy and falling bond yields allowed the government of Greece to run large structural deficits.

According to an editorial published by the Greek right-wing newspaper Kathimerini, large public deficits are one of the features that have marked the Greek social model since the restoration of democracy in 1974. After the removal of the right-wing military junta, the government wanted to bring disenfranchised left-leaning portions of the population into the economic mainstream.[6] In order to do so, successive Greek governments have, among other things, customarily run large deficits to finance public sector jobs, pensions, and other social benefits.[7] Since 1993 the ratio of debt to GDP has remained above 100%.[8]

Initially currency devaluation helped finance the borrowing. After the introduction of the euro in Jan 2001, Greece was initially able to borrow due to the lower interest rates government bonds could command. The late-2000s financial crisis that began in 2007 had a particularly large effect on Greece. Two of the country’s largest industries are tourism and shipping, and both were badly affected by the downturn with revenues falling 15% in 2009.[8]

To keep within the monetary union guidelines, the government of Greece had misreported the country’s official economic statistics.[9][10] In the beginning of 2010, it was discovered that Greece had paid Goldman Sachs and other banks hundreds of millions of dollars in fees since 2001 for arranging transactions that hid the actual level of borrowing.[11] The purpose of these deals made by several successive Greek governments was to enable them to continue spending while hiding the actual deficit from the EU.[12]

In 2009, the government of George Papandreou revised its deficit from an estimated 6% (8% if a special tax for building irregularities were not to be applied) to 12.7%.[13] In May 2010, the Greek government deficit was estimated to be 13.6%[14] which is one of the highest in the world relative to GDP.[15] Greek government debt was estimated at €216 billion in January 2010.[16] Accumulated government debt was forecast, according to some estimates, to hit 120% of GDP in 2010.[17] The Greek government bond market relies on foreign investors, with some estimates suggesting that up to 70% of Greek government bonds are held externally.[18]

Estimated tax evasion costs the Greek government over $20 billion per year.[19] Despite the crisis, Greek government bond auctions were over-subscribed in early January 2010 (as of 26 January).[20] According to the Financial Times on 25 January 2010, “Investors placed about €20bn ($28bn, £17bn) in orders for the five-year, fixed-rate bond, four times more than the (Greek) government had reckoned on.” In March, again according to the Financial Times, “Athens sold €5bn (£4.5bn) in 10-year bonds and received orders for three times that amount.”[21]


History of government debt and deficit (1999–present)
Source: EurostatELSTATMinFin
  1999 2000 20011 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 (estimates) 2012 (forecasts)
Public debt, billion €[22][23][24][25] 122.3 141 151.9 159.2 168 183.2 195.4 224.2 239.3 263.1 299.5 329.4 354.7/356.5 371.9/384.9
Public debt, % of GDP[22][23][25][24] 94 103.4 103.7 101.7 97.4 98.6 100 106.1 107.4 113.0 129.3 144.9 161.8/162.8 172.7/181.4
GDP growth, annual %[26][27][24][25] 3.4 3.5 4.2 3.4 5.9 4.4 2.3 5.5 3.0 −0.2 −3.2 −3.5/−5.5 −2.8/−5.5 0.7/−2.5
Budget deficit, % of GDP[28][23][25][24] −3.7 −4.5 −4.8 −5.6 −7.5 −5.2 −5.7 −6.5 −9.8 −15.8 −10.6 −8.5/−8.9 −6.8/−7

1 Year of entry into the Eurozone.

[edit]Downgrading of debt

On 27 April 2010, the Greek debt rating was decreased to the upper levels of ‘junk[29] status by Standard & Poor’s amidst hints of default by the Greek government.[30] Yields on Greek government two-year bonds rose to 15.3% following the downgrading.[31] Some analysts continue to question Greece’s ability to refinance its debt. Standard & Poor’s estimates that in the event of default investors would fail to get 30–50% of their money back.[30] Stock markets worldwide declined in response to this announcement.[32]

Following downgradings by Fitch and Moody’s, as well as Standard & Poor’s,[33] Greek bond yields rose in 2010, both in absolute terms and relative to German government bonds.[34] Yields have risen, particularly in the wake of successive ratings downgrading. According to The Wall Street Journal, “with only a handful of bonds changing hands, the meaning of the bond move isn’t so clear.”[35]

On 3 May 2010, the European Central Bank (ECB) suspended its minimum threshold for Greek debt “until further notice”,[36] meaning the bonds will remain eligible as collateral even with junk status. The decision will guarantee Greek banks’ access to cheap central bank funding, and analysts said it should also help increase Greek bonds’ attractiveness to investors.[37] Following the introduction of these measures the yield on Greek 10-year bonds fell to 8.5%, 550 basis points above German yields, down from 800 basis points earlier.[38] As of 22 September 2011, Greek 10-year bonds were trading at an effective yield of 23.6%, more than double the amount of the year before.[39]

[edit]Danger of default

Further information: Sovereign default


Interest rate of Greek two-year government bonds traded in the secondary marketreflecting the markets’ assessment of investment risk (source: Bloomberg).

Without a bailout agreement, there was a possibility that Greece would prefer to default on some of its debt. The premiums on Greek debt had risen to a level that reflected a high chance of a default or restructuring. Analysts gave a wide range of default probabilities, estimating a 25% to 90% chance of a default or restructuring.[40][41]

A default would most likely have taken the form of a restructuring where Greece would pay creditors, which include the up to €110 billion 2010 Greece bailout participants i.e. Eurozone governments and IMF, only a portion of what they were owed, perhaps 50 or 25 percent.[42] It has been claimed that this could destabilise the Euro Interbank Offered Rate, which is backed by government securities.[43]

Some experts have nonetheless argued that the best option at this stage for Greece is to engineer an “orderly default” on Greece’s public debt which would allow Athens to withdraw simultaneously from the eurozone and reintroduce a national currency, such as its historical drachma, at a debased rate[44](essentially, coining money). Economists who favor this approach to solve the Greek debt crisis typically argue that a delay in organising an orderly default would wind up hurting EU lenders and neighboring European countries even more.[45]

At the moment, because Greece is a member of the eurozone, it cannot unilaterally stimulate its economy with monetary policy. For example, the U.S. Federal Reserve expanded its balance sheet by over $1.3 trillion USD since the global financial crisis began, temporarily creating new money and injecting it into the system by purchasing outstanding debt, that money to be destroyed when the debt is paid back, later.[46]

[edit]International ramifications

Greece represents only 2.5% of the eurozone economy.[47] Despite its size, the danger is that a default by Greece will cause investors to lose faith in other eurozone countries. This concern is focused on Portugal and Ireland, both of whom have high debt and deficit issues.[48]Italy also has a high debt, but its budget position is better than the European average, and it is not considered among the countries most at risk.[49] Recent rumours raised by speculators about a Spanish bail-out were dismissed by Spanish Prime Minister José Luis Rodríguez Zapatero as “complete insanity” and “intolerable”.[50]

Spain has a comparatively low debt among advanced economies, at only 53% of GDP in 2010, more than 20 points less than Germany, France or the US, and more than 60 points less than Italy, Ireland or Greece,[51] and it does not face a risk of default.[52] Spain and Italy are far larger and more central economies than Greece; both countries have most of their debt controlled internally, and are in a better fiscal situation than Greece and Portugal, making a default unlikely unless the situation gets far more severe.[53]

[edit]Austerity packages

Greece adopted a number of austerity packages since 2010. According to research published on 5 May 2010 by Citibank, the fiscal tightening is “unexpectedly tough”. It will amount to a total of €30 billion (i.e. 12.5% of 2009 Greek GDP) and consist of 5% of GDP tightening in 2010 and a further 4% tightening in 2011.[54]

[edit]First austerity package

The first round came with the signing of the memorandums with the IMF and the ECB concerning a loan of 80 billion euro. The package was implemented on 9 February 2010 and included a freeze in the salaries of all government employees, a 10% cut in bonuses, as well as cuts in overtime workers, public employees and work-related travels.[55]

[edit]Second austerity package (Economy Protection Bill)

On 5 March 2010, amid new fears of bankruptcy, the Greek parliament passed the Economy Protection Bill, which was expected to save another €4.8 billion.[56] The measures include (in addition to the above):[57] 30% cuts in Christmas, Easter and leave of absence bonuses, a further 12% cut in public bonuses, a 7% cut in the salaries of public and private employees, a rise of VAT from 4.5% to 5%, from 9% to 10% and from 19% to 21%, a rise of tax on petrol to 15%, a rise in the (already existing) taxes on imported cars of up to 10%–30%, among others.

On 23 April 2010, after realizing the second austerity package failed to improve the country’s economic position, the Greek government requested that the EU/International Monetary Fund (IMF) bailout package be activated.[58] Greece needed money before 19 May, or it would face a debt roll over of $11.3bn.[59][60][61] The IMF had said it was “prepared to move expeditiously on this request”.[62]

Shortly after the European Commission, the IMF and ECB set up a tripartite committee (the Troika) to prepare an appropriate programme of economic policies underlying a massive loan. The Troika was led by Servaas Deroose, from the European Commission, and included also Poul Thomsen (IMF) and Klaus Masuch (ECB) as junior partners. In return the Greek government agreed to implement further measures.[63]

[edit]Third austerity package

On 1 May 2010, Prime Minister George Papandreou announced a new round of austerity measures, which have been described as “unprecedented”.[64] The proposed changes, which aim to save €38 billion through 2012, represent the biggest government overhaul in a generation.[65] The bill was submitted to Parliament on 4 May and approved on separate votes on 29 June and 30 June.[66][67] It was met with a nationwide general strike and massive protests the following day, with three people being killed, dozens injured, and 107 arrested.[65]

The measures include:[68][69][70]

  • An 8% cut on public sector allowances (in addition to the two previous austerity packages) and a 3% pay cut for DEKO (public sector utilities) employees.
  • Public sector limit of €1,000 introduced to bi-annual bonus, abolished entirely for those earning over €3,000 a month.
  • Limit of €500 per month to 13th and 14th month salaries of public employees; abolished for employees receiving over €3,000 a month.
  • Limit of €800 per month to 13th and 14th month pension installments; abolished for pensioners receiving over €2,500 a month.
  • Return of a special tax on high pensions.[which?]
  • Extraordinary taxes imposed on company profits.
  • Rise in the value of property (and thus higher taxes).
  • Rise of an additional 10% for all imported cars.
  • Changes were planned to the laws governing lay-offs and overtime pay.[specify]
  • Increases in value added tax to 23% (from 19%), 11% (from 9%) and 5.5% (from 4%).
  • 10% rise in luxury taxes and sin taxes on alcohol, cigarettes, and fuel.
  • Equalization of men’s and women’s pension age limits.
  • General pension age has not changed, but a mechanism has been introduced to scale them to life expectancy changes.
  • A financial stability fund has been created.[specify]
  • Average retirement age for public sector workers will be increased from 61 to 65.[71]
  • The number of public-owned companies shall be reduced from 6,000 to 2,000.[71]
  • The number of municipalities shall shrink from 1,000 to 400.[71]

On 2 May 2010, a loan agreement was reached between Greece, the other eurozone countries, and the International Monetary Fund. The deal consisted of an immediate €45 billion in loans to be provided in 2010, with more funds available later. A total of €110 billion has been agreed.[72][73] The interest for the eurozone loans is 5%, considered to be a rather high level for any bailout loan. The European Monetary Union loans will be pari passu and not senior like those of the IMF. In fact the seniority of the IMF loans themselves has no legal basis but is respected nonetheless. The loans should cover Greece’s funding needs for the next three years (estimated at €30 billion for the rest of 2010 and €40 billion each for 2011 and 2012).[54] According to EU officials, France and Germany[74] demanded that their military dealings with Greece be a condition of their participation in the financial rescue.[75]

As of 12 May 2010 the deficit was down 40 percent from the previous year.[71]

[edit]Fourth austerity package (Mid-term plan)

2011 saw the introduction of further austerity. In the midst of public discontent, massive protests and a 24-hour-strike throughout Greece,[76][77] the parliament debated on whether or not to pass a new austerity bill, known in Greece as the “mesoprothesmo” (the mid-term [plan]).[78][79] The government’s intent to pass further austerity measures was met with discontent from within the government and parliamentas well,[79] but was eventually passed with 155 votes in favor[78][79] (a marginal 5-seat majority). Horst Reichenbach headed up the task force overseeing Greek implementation of austerity and structural adjustment.[80]

The new measures included:[81][82] raise 50 billion euros by denationalizing companies and selling national property, an increase in taxes for anyone with a yearly income of over 8,000 euro, extra tax for anyone with a yearly income of over 12,000 euro, an increase in VAT in the housing industry, an extra tax of 2% for combating unemployment, an increase in taxes for pensioners by means of lower pensions ranging from 6% to 14% from the previous 4% to 10%, the creation of a specialized government body with the sole responsibility of exploiting national property, and others.

On 11 August 2011 the government introduced more taxes, this time targeted at people owning immovable property.[83] The new tax, which is to be paid through the owner’s electricity bill,[83] will affect 7.5 million Public Power Corporation accounts[83] and ranges from 3 to 20 euro per square meter.[84] The tax will apply for 2011–2012 and is expected to raise 4 billion Euro in revenue.[83]

On 19 August 2011 the Greek Minister of FinanceEvangelos Venizelos, said that new austerity measures “should not be necessary”.[85] On 20 August 2011 it was revealed that the government’s economic measures were still out of track;[86] government revenue went down by 1.9 billion euro while spending went up by 2.7 billion.[86]

On a meeting with representatives of the country’s economic sectors on 30 August 2011, the Prime Minister and the Minister of Finance acknowledged that some of the austerity measures were irrational,[87] such as the high VAT, and that they were forced to take them with a gun to the head.[87]

In October, Greek Prime Minister George Papandreou won parliamentary backing for the further austerity required, firstly, for the next instalment of international loans that were preventing a sovereign default and, secondly, to keep open the possibility of a partial write-off of Greek debt at forthcoming EU summit.[88] At this summit on combating the EU sovereign debt crisis,[88] Greece was granted a quid pro quoof further austerity for a €100bn loan and a 50% debt reduction.[89] Within a week, Papandreou, backed unanimously by his cabinet, announced a referendum on the deal, sending shockwaves through the financial markets.[90][91] The prime minister’s announcement also resulted in the issuance of an ultimatum on Greece’s eurozone membership by Angela Merkel and Nicolas Sarkozy who declared that, unless the proposed referendum quickly affirmed the agreed-to summit plan, they would withhold an already overdue €6bn loan payment to Athens, money that Greece needed by mid-December.[90][92] Papandreou cancelled the referendum the next day, saying that it was no longer needed now the opposition New Democracy Party had given backing to the agreement.[90]

Papandreou resigned as prime minister on 10th November,[93] and was replaced temporarily by unelected technocrat Lucas Papademos who was to promulgate laws associated with implementing the EU summit plan; his appointment was criticised by left-wing parties and branded “unconstitutional”.[94] By contrast, three separate polls taken when Papademos assumed office revealed that around 75% of Greeks thought that temporary, emergency technocratic rule was “positive”.[94] The EU insisted that whichever government was elected after Papademos in 2012, it must be bound to honour the agreed upon EU-IMF austerity strategy.[95] It thus demanded that Greek party-political leaders sign legally-binding letters to this effect, as well as to any additional measures that might be required in future as part of the second rescue-package.[95] Papademos argued in favour of signing, even in the face of opposition from major pro-austerity factions in his government.[95]Such letters would bind Greek governments to austerity and structural adjustment through to 2020.[95] At the end of December, it was announced that the general election to replace Papademos’ technocratic administration was to be delayed until April 2012, as more time was needed to finalise plans for austerity and structural adjustment, as well as to complete negotiations over the Greek debt reduction.[96]

Inspectors from the troika will assess how the Papademos government has improved on that of Papanderou in meeting the targets of the first bail-out scheme, as well as how it has begun to institute the second programme.[96][97]

[edit]Objections to proposed policies

Syntagma Square 'indignados'.png

The crisis is seen as a justification for imposing fiscal austerity[98]on Greece in exchange for European funding which would lower borrowing costs for the Greek government.[99] The negative impact of tighter fiscal policy could offset the positive impact of lower borrowing costs and social disruption could have a significantly negative impact on investment and growth in the longer term.Joseph Stiglitz has also criticised the EU for being too slow to help Greece, insufficiently supportive of the new government, lacking the will power to set up sufficient “solidarity and stabilisation framework” to support countries experiencing economic difficulty, and too deferential to bond rating agencies.[100]

As an alternative to the bailout agreement, Greece could have left the eurozone. Wilhelm Hankel, professor emeritus of economics at the Goethe University Frankfurt suggested[101] in an article published in the Financial Times that the preferred solution to the Greek bond ‘crisis’ is a Greek exit from the euro followed by a devaluation of the currency. Fiscal austerity or a euro exit is the alternative to accepting differentiated government bond yields within the Euro Area. If Greece remains in the euro while accepting higher bond yields, reflecting its high government deficit, then high interest rates would dampen demand, raise savings and slow the economy. An improved trade performance and less reliance on foreign capital would be the result.[citation needed] Polls have shown that despite the awful sitution, the vast majority of Greeks are not in favour of leaving the eurozone.[102]

In the documentary Debtocracy made by a group of Greek journalists, it is argued that Greece should create an audit commission, and force bondholders to suffer from losses, like Ecuador did.

On a poll published on 18 May 2011, 62% of the people questioned felt that the IMF memorandum that Greece signed in 2010 was a bad decision that hurt the country, while 80% had no faith in the Minister of FinanceGiorgos Papakonstantinou, to handle the crisis.[103]Evangelos Venizelos replaced Mr. Papakonstantinou on 17 June. 75% of those polled gave a negative image of the IMF, and 65% feel it is hurting Greece’s economy.[103] 64% felt that the possibility of bankruptcy is likely, and when asked about their fears for the near future, polls showed a fear of: unemployment (97%), poverty (93%) and the closure of businesses (92%).[103]

The social effects of the Greek austerity measures have been severe, including on poor and needy foreign immigrants, with even some Greek citizens turning to NGOs for healthcare treatment,[104] and had to give up children for adoption.[105] On 17 October 2011 Minister of FinanceEvangelos Venizelos announced that the government would establish a new fund, aimed at helping those who were hit the hardest from the government’s austerity measures.[106] The money for this agency will come from the profits made by tackling tax evasion.[106]

[edit]See also

%d bloggers like this: